Commit Graph

4 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
12c0e5ca74 Wave 3 exit - record what the wave actually changed on screen
wave-3.md asks for "no unintended visual change on any page versus wave 2".
Measured with tests/token_check.py, b105135 against the end of the wave, all 7
pages: 7 elements changed and all 7 are the fixes the wave was for - two
.user-pick selects going white (T3.4) and five green action buttons going blue
(T3.5). The other 3,493 elements compute exactly what they computed at the end of
wave 2, and all 178 wave-2 token names resolve to the same literals.

Three fixes are invisible to a computed-style diff and are recorded with how they
were verified instead: two green buttons that need application state the fixture
does not reach, and the sentence-case pass, which changes text rather than style.

The one exit criterion not met is carried forward explicitly rather than ticked:
T3.2's "no page stylesheet declares a raw spacing or type value" is complete for
colour and open for spacing and type (BL-010).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-15 19:13:42 -05:00
ce6fb840f0 T3.5 - A5: one button system, and green goes back to being a status
251 buttons across the 7 pages, counted in the browser with every wizard step,
creator section and tool panel forced visible. Two thirds of them are
display:none at load, so a static grep sees about eighty and misses the rest.

FOUR ROLES, defined once in theme-light.css as --wp-btn-*, and no fifth:

  primary    the one action the screen exists for. Filled accent.
  secondary  every other real action. White, --border-strong, accent on hover.
  tertiary   navigating or undoing. No fill, no border, accent text.
  danger     destructive. Outlined red; filled red only where the control is too
             small for an outline to read - the 28px x on a sequence row.

Every button class is mapped to a role in docs/reference/tokens.md section 12.
No value is new: these are the fills the sheets already rendered, given one
definition so that "primary" means one thing.

GREEN IS A STATUS COLOUR AND NO LONGER FILLS A BUTTON. A5 names two green action
buttons; there are four. .use-btn and the launcher's completed-SOP card button
never render green in the default fixture, so the review could not have seen
them - the SOP has to be finished and a suggested value has to be offered first.

  .nav-btn.primary            "SOP complete"    wizard
  .btn.btn-generate           "Save & view"     creator
  .use-btn                                      creator
  .card.complete .card-button                   launcher

The green did not go anywhere. .cstatus button.on-cleared, .toggle-btn.enabled,
.wp-nav-dot.ok, .rb-ready, .badge-R and the launcher card's own left border and
status line all still carry it, and every one of those is a state rather than an
action. The launcher card in particular still says "complete" twice after this
change; it just no longer says it on the button.

SENTENCE CASE, applied to buttons and field labels only, which is the scope A5
sets. First word capitalised, the rest lowercased, acronyms and external proper
nouns left alone (SOP, QC, WP, UPN, PM/APM/CM/QM, PDF, JSON, CSV, BIM, MIMO,
Excel, Acumatica).

  ~30 button labels across launcher, wizard, creator, admin and two scripts
  46 field labels
  text-transform:uppercase removed from 4 rules - .btn and .add-btn (creator
  buttons), label and .cmt-namebar label (creator field labels)

Labels carrying markup - a .req asterisk, a .help-tip chip - had only their text
nodes transformed, so the markup survives and "first word" means the first word
of the label rather than of each fragment. The creator's mono face, 10px size and
tracking are its idiom and are untouched; only the forced uppercase goes.

help.js was updated too. It names "Load Sample" and "SOP Complete" in prose, so
renaming the buttons without it would have left the help centre describing
controls that no longer exist. That coupling is the only place in the app where
button text is referenced by name.

Verified by re-running the inventory: 0 green action buttons, 0 uppercase button
labels, 251 buttons still present - nothing was lost in the rename.

console.css card headers are unchanged, confirmed by diff: the only six lines
this task touches in that file are token substitutions on button/button.primary/
button.danger, none of them within twenty lines of .card h2.

f_items 5 FIXED / F6 REPRODUCES. browser_check 71/71.

Left alone and logged: .step-tab is still uppercase (BL-015) - it is a stepper
tab, neither a button nor a field label, and A4/S9 rebuild the stepper. Table
headers, section eyebrows and headings keep their case throughout. BL-008 and
BL-009 were re-targeted from T3.5 to wave 9: both are colour merges on a field
fill and a status pill, and this task is scoped to buttons.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-15 19:11:56 -05:00
9ab7b48de2 T3.2 - C3/S5: one source of truth for colour; page sheets alias only
theme-light.css is now the only file in html/ that contains a colour literal.
The five page stylesheets and all four inline <style> blocks declare names and
nothing else.

  theme-light.css                 191 declarations, 175 with a literal value
  console.css                      28 declarations,   0
  work-package-suite-styles.css    16 declarations,   0
  wp-chrome.css                    14 declarations,   0
  wp-creation-styles.css           24 declarations,   0
  wp-sidenav.css                    0 declarations,   0

#0f62fe is declared in one sheet, down from five. The eleven occurrences left
inside theme-light.css are Carbon's own v10-to-v11 alias layer, which the
inventory records as deliberate and not the S5 defect.

Names were kept, because 111 var() references live in .js files across 23 token
names and a rename there fails silently - no build error, no console warning,
just an unstyled element.

The rule the refactor was built on: consolidation is not unification. Where two
sheets declared the same value, they collapse. Where they declared DIFFERENT
values for one role - the two shadows, the eight status borders doing four jobs,
the three mono stacks - each value got its own canonical name and the pair is
recorded for T3.5. Picking a winner between two near-identical greys is a
rendered change, which this task forbids. The console's zebra stripe is the one
that would have bitten: #fafafa is six points from #f4f4f4, and merging them
erases the striping on the nine-column user table.

Collecting the one-offs in one place made two things countable that were not
before: twelve distinct shadows, and a ninth amber (#8a6d00 on the field view,
four points from #8e6a00 and doing the same job - BL-009).

VERIFICATION - the screenshot done-when could not do the job, so it was replaced.

Captured against wave 2, 11 of 14 shots were pixel-identical and 3 were not.
Capturing wave 2 against ITSELF produced the same 3 differences at the same
bounding box, so those shots cannot distinguish a regression from the clock.
Trap 2 in the brief is half wrong: users.html is stable at both widths; the
unstable third is the creator at 1440px, and admin's captured page height varies
by ~600px between runs (BL-012).

So tests/token_check.py was added. It checks what wave 3 actually claims: that
every custom property resolves to the same literal, and every element computes
the same colours, shadows and type. That is stronger than a screenshot - it
covers the hover, focus and disabled rules a screenshot never exercises, and it
is deterministic.

  wave 2 vs T3.2, all 7 pages:
  178/178 wave-2 token names resolve identically, +213 new
  3,500 elements compute identically, zero added, zero removed
  16 tokens differ in notation only (#fff -> #ffffff), which is the duplicate
  class this task existed to collapse

Two detours worth not repeating: the element walk was first keyed by sibling
index and reported 55 phantom differences on the SOP page, where three
JS-injected overlays append in whichever order their async work finishes
(BL-011); and the comparator now normalises notation before reporting, because
otherwise it fails on its own success.

f_items 5 FIXED / F6 REPRODUCES as expected. browser_check 71/71.

ONE DONE-WHEN NOT MET, recorded rather than skipped: "no page stylesheet
declares a raw color, spacing or type value". The colour half is met in full.
483 raw spacing values, 281 font-sizes and 65 radii remain inside rules, 492 of
them in the creator. That is arithmetic, not effort: the creator's spacing is
every integer from 1px to 14px, so no token exists that padding:9px 11px maps to
without changing one of the numbers - and this task forbids changing a rendered
value. The two requirements are mutually exclusive. Logged as BL-010 for T5.x
and T7.1, where those pages are re-laid-out and the values get chosen again.

New backlog: BL-009 (ninth amber), BL-010 (raw spacing/type in rules),
BL-011 (overlay append race), BL-012 (unstable screenshot targets).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-15 18:50:30 -05:00
0e40e967a0 T3.1 - C3/S5: inventory the token systems, and correct the accent baseline
Produces docs/reference/tokens.md. No stylesheet is touched; T3.1 is inventory.

What the inventory found that the plan did not say:

- It is six stylesheets plus the launcher's inline <style>, not four (D1 again).
  202 custom-property declarations, all listed with file and line.
- The wave 0 accent baseline is wrong: 15 declarations across 5 sheets, not 14
  across 4. console.css:13 packs five declarations onto one line and the
  baseline's `^\s*--` regex only ever matches the first, so console's own
  --accent was never counted. Corrected command is in tokens.md section 10.
  The wave 9 target of one sheet is unchanged; there is one more to remove.
- Three mono stacks, not two. The file map recorded console.css dropping
  ui-monospace and Segoe UI Mono; wp-chrome.css:159,221 is a third stack that
  drops Cascadia Mono and Segoe UI Mono.
- --shadow-lg does not differ by blur, as the file map says. Both are
  0 4px 16px. The difference is the colour: rgba(0,0,0,.16) against
  rgba(20,30,50,.12). That means they can be unified later with no layout
  consequence at all.
- Twelve var() fallbacks can never fire, because the token they fall back from
  is declared at :root on a sheet the page loads. Free deletions for T3.2.
- --shadow: none is a no-op token with 8 consumers. Left for T3.3, which is
  hunting exactly this class of silent nothing.
- 111 var() references live in .js files across 23 token names. A rename there
  fails silently - no build error, no console warning, just an unstyled
  element. Section 9 is the list to grep before deleting any alias.
- There is a second brand blue: #2563d6, filling .sop-inherited at 7% alpha on
  every field a work package inherited from its SOP. Logged as BL-008.

The document states one rule up front, because it is the difference between a
clean wave 3 and a broken one: consolidation is not unification. Where two
sheets declare the same value, T3.2 collapses them. Where they declare
different values for the same role - the two banner greens, the three error
borders, the two shadows - each value gets its own canonical name and the pair
is recorded. Picking a winner between two near-identical greys is a visual
change, which T3.2 forbids.

Section 8 computes the near-duplicates rather than eyeballing them. The one to
watch is the zebra stripe: console's #fafafa sits six points from #f4f4f4, and
collapsing them erases the striping on the nine-column user table.

New backlog entries: BL-004 (help.js ships 52 colours in a different design
language), BL-005 (two modals styled entirely by inline style= attributes),
BL-006 (17 half-pixel font sizes), BL-007 (--radius: 0 contradicted 45 times in
the sheet that declares it), BL-008 (the second blue).

One decision T3.2 needs and this task cannot make: adopting the superset mono
stack changes the rendered face on machines that have Segoe UI Mono or
ui-monospace but not IBM Plex Mono, which is most of the target environment.
That is a real change on admin and users. Either accept it and re-shoot those
two baselines - capturing twice, since they are not byte-stable - or keep
console.css's narrower stack as a second token until T3.5. Written up in
tokens.md section 6d and 8-H; built to neither until it is answered.

Verification: f_items 5 FIXED / F6 REPRODUCES as expected, browser_check
71/71. Screenshots not applicable - this task changes no rendered surface.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-15 18:24:52 -05:00